Is Pilbara Minerals (ASX: PLS) the best way to play lithium on the ASX?

Nick Sundich Nick Sundich, April 14, 2022

The rise in demand for electronic devices, particularly electric vehicles, has been a boon for companies such as Pilbara Minerals (ASX: PLS). But how does it fare against the competition?

 

GET A 30-DAY FREE TRIAL TO STOCKS DOWN UNDER

 

Pilbara Minerals owns one of the world’s largest lithium mines

Pilbara Minerals’ Pilgangoora project is set to be one of the world’s biggest lithium mines. It lies 120km from Port Hedland and is one of the largest deposits of lithium spodumene and tantalum in the world. Spodumene is the mineral that yields lithium while tantalum is valuable for its use in electronics and alloy metals given its corrosion-resistant properties.

Pilgangoora is a hard rock project, which is costlier to mine than underground brine deposits. But beggars for lithium cannot be choosers. Only hard rock lithium can convert directly to lithium hydroxide – the chemical that might be needed over lithium carbonate to improve energy density in batteries in the years ahead.

 

Pilbara Minerals

Pilbara Minerals (ASX:PLS) price chart, log scale (Source: Tradingview)

 

After a volatile 3 years, the company is stronger than ever

Pilgangoora began commercial production three year ago – in April 2019. The first 12 months were tough because of the oversupply in the lithium market and, in early 2020, the Corona Crash. But the share price recovered in conjunction with the lithium price and increased demand for electric vehicles. Governments have made their carbon emission targets clearer, ushering in a new era of electric powered transportation. And the rise of Tesla has led to almost all other car manufacturers scrambling to catch up.

 

The Asian connection

Pilbara Minerals timed its run perfectly, signing a five-year offtake agreement with Chinese lithium producer Yibin Tianyi back on 25 March 2020. And in October of that year, it bought the Altura Lithium Operations for US$175m, expanding the Pilgangoora operation and leveraging the lithium price recovery. Beyond its lithium resource, the company is building a 6MW solar farm at Pilgangoora and has a joint venture agreement with POSCO to develop a lithium hydroxide conversion facility in South Korea. Pilbara Minerals’ share price has risen from 22 cents two years ago to $2.93 today – a gain of over 1,200%!

 

Set for significant growth

In FY21, Pilbara Minerals shipped 281,440 dry metric tonnes (dmt) of spodumene concentrate, up from 116,256dm in FY20. It’s EBITDA was $26.6m, up from a $33.9m EBITDA loss in FY20. In 1HY22 it has increased its sales and production, shipping 170,228 dmt of spodumene concentrate and generating $291.7m in sales and $151.1m in EBITDA. On 12 April 2022, the company confirmed it was on track to achieve its guidance of 340-380,000dmt so long as there were no COVID-19 interruptions.

Consensus estimates are very optimistic about the company’s growth in FY23, tipping $2.45bn in EBITDA. This means it is only trading at 3.8x EV/EBITDA and 5.5x P/E. But these would be significant growth assumptions from FY21 even with full year FY22 spodumene production expected to be 340-380,000dmt.

 

Closest peer Mineral Resources is less of a pure play

Turning our attention to its closest peer Mineral Resources (ASX: MIN), which also has a West Australian spodumene asset (two in fact) and a lithium hydroxide conversion plant in a joint venture – in its case with NYSE-listed Albemarle Corporation – as well as a processing facility with Jiangxi Ganfeng Lithium Co.

Consensus estimates are for $4.84bn in revenue and $1.86bn in EBITDA for FY23 which prices it at 6.3x EV/EBITDA and 11.5x P/E. But Mineral Resources is a company that recorded $1.9bn in EBITDA in FY21, meaning it has been virtually flat for two years, However, we would note it also has iron ore, gas and mining services assets and has seen volatile conditions there. The company is exporting 450kt to 475kt dmt from Mt Marion alone and although production is suspended at its other asset, Wodinga, it hopes to restart by the end of FY22.

 

Do you like pure plays?

It’s clear lithium is a great space to be in right now and will be for some time to come. But the question of which company you invest in comes down to your risk appetite and whether or not you believe that Pilbara Minerals can achieve the growth that is expected in the months ahead. If you like diversification, Mineral Resources might be the one for you, given that Pilbara Mineralsis much more of a pure play. Personally, we prefer pure plays any day of the week.

 

Stay up-to-date on ASX-listed lithium stocks!

 

Make sure you subscribe to Stocks Down Under today

 

GET A 30-DAY FREE TRIAL

 

No credit card needed and the trial expires automatically.

 

Frequently Asked Questions about Pilbara Minerals

Recent Posts

CCV

Cash Converters (ASX: CCV) remains strong in a weak market

Who is Cash Converters?  Cash Converters International (ASX: CCV) operates as a sub-prime, non-bank lender and second-hand retailer. The company…

Solar Energy Stocks

The best Solar Energy Stocks on ASX in 2022

What are the best Solar Energy Stocks to invest in in 2022 Australia is at the forefront of renewable energy…

Woodside

Woodside Petroleum (ASX: WPL) is up over 34% this year. But can it go further?

The oil and gas sector has been among the few bright spots in the market in 2022 and Woodside Petroleum…