Bendigo Bank Drops on A$50M Charge: Bargain or Value Trap?

Bendigo and Adelaide Bank (ASX: BEN) shares slipped to A$10.10 yesterday after APRA slapped the regional lender with a A$50 million capital charge. At the same time, AUSTRAC announced it’s launching a formal investigation into the bank’s money laundering controls. The double hit from regulators has left the stock under pressure. The big question now: is this sell-off a buying opportunity or a sign of bigger problems ahead?

The trouble started after an independent Deloitte review found serious gaps in how Bendigo spots and stops money laundering. APRA Chair John Lonsdale said the regulator is “concerned there may be significant gaps in its risk management framework.” We believe that’s a red flag investors shouldn’t ignore.

What are the Best ASX Bank stocks to invest in right now?

Check our buy/sell tips

A$50 Million Is Just the Start

The A$50 million capital charge kicks in from 1 January 2026. It will reduce Bendigo’s key capital ratio (CET1) by about 17 basis points. On paper, the bank still looks healthy. Its CET1 ratio was 11.19% at the end of November, which sits above APRA’s “unquestionably strong” benchmark.

But here’s the catch: this charge won’t go away until Bendigo fixes its problems and satisfies APRA. The timeline is unclear, and the bank hasn’t said how much the fix will cost. CEO Richard Fennell admitted the bank needs to “intensify focus and efforts” on risk management. In our view, that signals expensive remediation work ahead.

APRA has also ordered a deeper review that goes beyond money laundering. The regulator wants to know if similar weaknesses exist across the whole bank. This suggests APRA sees it as a company-wide issue, not just a one-branch problem.

The Real Risk: AUSTRAC’s Unknown Penalty

While the A$50 million charge grabs headlines, we believe the bigger threat is AUSTRAC’s open investigation. The regulator has flagged a “wide range of possible enforcement actions” but hasn’t decided what penalty to impose.

For context, Westpac paid A$1.3 billion in 2020 for money laundering failures. Commonwealth Bank paid A$700 million. Bendigo’s situation looks less severe, but penalties in the hundreds of millions are possible. Some brokers have flagged worst-case scenarios of A$500 million or more.
Until AUSTRAC shows its hand, investors are flying blind on the real cost of this mess.

The Investor’s Takeaway: Still Avoid

The roughly 6.2% dividend yield looks attractive, especially compared to the big four banks at 4% to 5%. But we believe the risks outweigh the rewards.

Here’s our concern: if AUSTRAC imposes a large penalty, that dividend could be at risk. The bank is also preparing to integrate its RACQ Bank acquisition, adding A$2.7 billion in loans and A$2.5 billion in deposits. That deal makes sense for growth, but it adds complexity when management should focus on fixing compliance.
For existing shareholders, holding the stock makes sense, but adding more is risky. The RACQ deal is good for the long term, yet regulatory uncertainty clouds the short term.

For new investors, it’s safer to wait. Buying before AUSTRAC’s decision means taking on unknown risk, and it’s better to miss the early part of a recovery than to buy too soon and face losses. Our view would change if AUSTRAC confirms penalties of A$200 million and the dividend remains secure. Until then, Bendigo looks more like a trap than a bargain.