Capricorn Metals (ASX:CMM) Drops on Yalgoo Acquisition: Buy the Dip?

Capricorn Metals: Dilution or opportunity?

Capricorn Metals (ASX: CMM) closed down 1.76% at A$14.52 yesterday despite announcing a deal that grows its Western Australian gold footprint. The company signed a binding agreement with Tempest Minerals to buy the Yalgoo Project for A$4.5 million, with most of the payment coming through new shares. For investors, this raises a simple question: Is the market overreacting to dilution concerns, or is this a fair price adjustment?

The deal structure explains why some shareholders sold. Capricorn will pay an initial cash deposit of A$100,000, with a further A$400,000 in cash payable upon the completion of the deal. This means existing shareholders own a slightly smaller piece of the company.

However, what the market may be missing is what this deal actually delivers: the gold and base metal rights over 1,000 square kilometres of promising ground (with the seller retaining iron ore rights), sitting right next to Capricorn’s recently acquired Golden Range and Fields Find projects.

What are the Best ASX Gold stocks to invest in right now?

Check our buy/sell tips

Yalgoo Fits Into Capricorn Metal’s Bigger Picture

Capricorn has been buying up land around its Mt Gibson Gold Project all year. Announced in July 2025 and completed in November, the company’s acquisition of Warriedar Resources added the Golden Range and Fields Find projects with 2.3 million ounces of gold equivalent (AuEq) resources, which includes Australia’s largest open-pit antimony deposit. Before that came the Mummaloo and Kings Find acquisitions. Yalgoo is the next piece of this puzzle.

Executive Chairman Mark Clark called the project “highly prospective” for gold, with multiple target zones that could host economic deposits. The land sits next to mines owned by major players like 29 Metals and Spartan Resources. This suggests the ground has real potential.

We believe the deal structure shows smart money management. Rather than spending Capricorn’s cash reserves of around A$356 million, the company kept its cash while still securing valuable exploration ground.

Why the Market Sold Off Despite Good News

The dip comes down to one thing: dilution. When a company issues new shares to pay for something, existing shareholders own a smaller percentage of the business. Some investors don’t like this, even when the acquisition makes strategic sense.

But here’s the key point: the contingent payments are structured to protect Capricorn’s downside. The deal includes milestone payments of up to A$1.5 million in total, payable across a maximum of three tenements. Specifically, Tempest receives A$750,000 if a JORC-compliant resource of over 75,000 ounces is identified, and another A$750,000 if the Capricorn Board makes a formal decision to commence mining. This structure protects Capricorn Metals if exploration fails.

The deal is expected to close in early 2026, with drilling set to begin shortly after. If Yalgoo delivers discoveries, today’s sellers may regret their decision.

The Investor’s Takeaway for Capricorn Metals

The bullish case is simple. Capricorn Metals has built a resource base of roughly 9.1 million ounces, underpinned by a significant upgrade to 4.0 million ounces in group ore reserves announced in October 2025. Mt Gibson alone holds a 4.5 million ounce mineral resource estimate and 2.74 million ounces in reserves, with a 17-year mine life once production starts. Adding cheap exploration ground around this core asset makes sense for long-term growth.

However, valuation is a concern. With a price-to-earnings ratio of approximately 38.3x, Capricorn Metals trades at a significant premium to the ASX metals and mining sector average of around 23x. The stock price already assumes strong growth ahead.

Our view is that existing shareholders should hold through this dip. The small pullback looks like profit-taking after a strong run, not a fundamental problem. But new investors may want to wait. A better entry point could come if shares pull back towards the A$13-14 range.

Watch for drilling results in 2026. These will show whether Yalgoo becomes a real ore source or just an expensive land package.