Chairman Chaney concedes the share price disappointed and signals openness on CEO search and asset reviews.
Northern Star Resources (ASX:NST) has published a shareholder letter from Chairman Michael Chaney directly addressing Elliott Investment Management, the US activist fund that disclosed a 3 to 4% stake in the gold miner last week.
Elliott has gone public with a presentation pushing for a faster CEO appointment, board renewal, a possible sale of the company, and a spin-out of smaller assets. The letter is Chaney’s measured response, and it carries more concessions than the polite tone suggests.
- Updated
- INSIDER CONVICTION TRADES FY26
The market hasn't noticed yet.
Disclosed by law. Missed by most investors. 129 trades tracked by us.
NO Credit card
- Director buys & sells tracked
- Buy / Hold / Sell verdict on every stock
- Technical analysis included
The Chairman opens by admitting the share price performance has not met the board’s expectations, which is a notable acknowledgement given Northern Star has shed a meaningful chunk of its market value over the past year. He then addresses each Elliott proposal, agreeing with some and pushing back firmly on the sale-of-company idea.
For investors, the more interesting question is not what Elliott proposed but what the board has now publicly committed to consider.
What Elliott wants and where the board already agrees
Elliott’s presentation pushed four levers. Move quickly on a new CEO, refresh the board with deep gold experience, run a sale process, and consider spinning out smaller assets into a separately listed vehicle.
Chaney’s letter agrees with the first two in substance. The CEO search following Stuart Tonkin’s announced exit is already underway with an international search firm, and the board has been hunting for an additional director with deep gold experience for the past year. Chaney himself flags his retirement in November, so board renewal is happening regardless.
On the sale process, the board is clear it has fielded several corporate approaches over the past year and rejected them. The spin-out idea has also been studied. Investment banks pitched it in the last six months and the financial adviser reviewed it.
Why the activist showed up now
Northern Star cut production guidance more than once during FY26 as the ageing mill struggled and Jundee output slipped. The stock collapsed from above A$31 to the high A$teens. The A$500 million buyback announced in April 2026 signalled management thought the stock was cheap, but the share price kept underperforming the gold price.
That gap between a record A$1.9 billion first-half FY26 underlying EBITDA and a sliding share price is exactly the kind of valuation dislocation activists look for. The KCGM mill expansion at Fimiston, on track for commissioning early in FY27, is supposed to be the catalyst that closes the gap.
Worth noting, Chaney specifically confirms the Fimiston build is nearing completion, on time, with a cost overrun he describes as modest by Australian project standards. That is a pointed line aimed at investors who have heard a lot of bad operational news lately.
The sale-of-company line is the one to watch
The most important sentence in the letter is the one where Chaney confirms multiple corporate approaches were received over the past year and turned away. In other words suitors exist but have been turned away.
Our take is that Elliott’s intervention raises the bar the board now has to clear to keep saying no. If another approach lands at a credible premium, it becomes harder to dismiss when a 3 to 4% activist holder is publicly arguing the company is undervalued.
The Investors Takeaway for Northern Star Resources
The next 12 months are now framed by two clocks running in parallel. One is the operational clock around Fimiston commissioning, Hemi approvals, and a new CEO landing with credibility. The other is the activist clock, where Elliott will be measuring board responsiveness against the share price.
We think shareholders who held through the bad year now have a more interesting setup than they had a week ago. The buyback is still running, the cash flow is real, and there is now a sophisticated holder publicly pushing for value realisation.
Investors can read our prior coverage of the CEO transition at stocksdownunder.
