Ramelius Resources (ASX:RMS) Drops 6% on Q1 Results: Buy the Dip or Warning Sign?

Ramelius Resources (ASX:RMS) shares tumbled 5.86% to $3.30 this morning after the mid-tier gold producer released September quarter results revealing a sharp production decline despite maintaining fortress-like financials. The company reported gold production of 55,013 ounces at an All-In Sustaining Cost (AISC) of A$1,836 per ounce, down 25% from 73,454 ounces in the June quarter.

The market reaction highlights a classic dilemma: strong balance sheet versus weakening operations. While production disappointed, Ramelius ended the quarter with $827.7 million in cash and gold, up from $809.7 million previously, and declared a fully-franked dividend of $0.05 per share.

What are the Best ASX stocks to invest in right now?

Check our buy/sell tips

Production Slump: Temporary or Structural?

The 25% decline wasn’t entirely unexpected, but its magnitude rattled investors. This continues a downward trend from 85,311 ounces produced in December 2024, suggesting sustained operational headwinds rather than a one-off event.

Mount Magnet processed lower-grade ore zones while Edna May’s transition to care and maintenance resulted in $4.1 million in costs and a 41% drop in mill grade to 1.19 grams per tonne. The company is also navigating integration complexities following its Spartan Resources acquisition.

The critical question: is this temporary? Ramelius releases its Rebecca-Roe Definitive Feasibility Study and Mount Magnet/Dalgaranga integration studies on October 28, along with a five-year outlook and detailed FY26 guidance. These announcements should clarify whether Q1 represents the low point.

Fortress Balance Sheet Provides Buffer

In July, Ramelius completed its $2.4 billion acquisition of Spartan Resources, bringing the high-grade Dalgaranga gold project into the portfolio at a net cost of just $74.3 million after accounting for cash acquired.

Despite subdued production, cash generation stayed strong. When combined with an undrawn debt facility of $175 million, total available liquidity exceeds $1 billion. Gold traded around $4,083 per ounce on October 26, still up approximately 48.77% year-over-year, meaning even reduced output generates substantial cash flow.

The fully-franked final dividend of $0.05 per share brought total FY25 dividends to $0.08 per share—a 60% increase over FY24, demonstrating management confidence.

The 500,000 Ounce Ambition

Ramelius aims to become a 500,000+ ounce per annum producer by FY30—more than double its current ~220,000 ounce annualised rate. The company’s mineral resources expanded to 12 million ounces with ore reserves of 2.4 million ounces, up 38% and 118% respectively from 2024.

Management is backing this vision aggressively. The Board approved an increased FY26 exploration budget of $80-100 million, with $18.8 million already spent in Q1. Early results show promise, with intercepts at Never Never including 43.5m at 11.7g/t gold and 27.6m at 14.4g/t gold.

Peer Comparison

Northern Star Resources (ASX:NST) operates at far greater scale with record $536 million free cash flow and 1.6 million ounces of gold production in 2025, though it too saw shares decline approximately 9% during the recent gold correction.

Evolution Mining (ASX:EVN) delivered standout performance with shares rising approximately 100% over the past year and record net mine cash flow of $366 million for the September quarter.

Ramelius sits between these peers in scale, offering stronger growth optionality through Dalgaranga integration but facing execution risk.

Key Risks

Execution uncertainty: The 500,000+ ounce vision depends heavily on successfully integrating Mount Magnet and Dalgaranga operations. Until October 28 guidance, clarity is lacking.

Rising capital intensity: Rebecca-Roe requires significant investment, while stamp duty expenses of $130-140 million related to the Spartan transaction will impact FY26 earnings.

Gold volatility: The metal experienced its biggest intraday drop since 2013 in late October, falling nearly $300 per ounce. Further corrections would compress margins.

Our Take: Wait for October 28 Guidance

Ramelius presents a nuanced case. The bull case rests on robust cash generation, credible growth strategy, and high-grade assets. The bear case centres on production uncertainty and execution risk.

For existing shareholders, hold through the upcoming guidance. October 28 announcements should clarify whether Q1 was an aberration or signals persistent issues.

New investors should wait for clarity. While the 6% decline creates opportunity, confirmation of production stabilisation reduces risk. Conservative investors should demand evidence before buying, while aggressive investors might view this as opportunity ahead of positive guidance.