Michael Hill (ASX:MHJ): This Under Pressure Jewellery Outlet Is Trying To Position Itself As An AI Play

In this era, every company is trying to position itself as an AI play – even jewellery retailer Michael Hill (ASX:MHJ). Given the leadership vacuum with the deaths of former CEO Daniel Bracken and Sir Michael Hill, not to mention the subdued consumer environment…investors wouldn’t be condemned for asking: What now? The company just held an Investor Day and told investors the future it envisioned.

What are the Best ASX Stocks to invest in right now?

Check our buy/sell tips

Overview Of Michael Hill

Michael Hill began in 1979 as a single store in the northern New Zealand city of Whangārei, built around Sir Michael Hill’s belief that jewellery retailing could be more theatrical, more design‑led, and more customer‑centric than the traditional model. The business expanded steadily across New Zealand through the 1980s, entered Australia in 1987, and later Canada in 2002, where the brand found a receptive market for its accessible luxury positioning.

Over four decades the company evolved from a founder‑driven retailer into a listed, multi‑market jewellery group with a strong bridal and diamond heritage, a loyal customer base, and a reputation for disciplined execution. The passing of Sir Michael Hill and, shortly after, CEO Daniel Bracken in 2025 marked the end of an era, yet the company today stands more streamlined and strategically coherent than at any point in its recent history.

The Michael Hill brand remains the Group’s core engine, while Canada has emerged as its most compelling growth market, with lower brand maturity, higher digital headroom, and a clear runway for store expansion. Bevilles, acquired in 2023, sits at the value end of the portfolio and is undergoing a disciplined reset designed to prove unit economics before any further rollout. Together, the two brands position the Group to compete across both value and accessible luxury segments in a subdued but resilient consumer environment.

A Business Reframed, Not Repaired

The core narrative running through the deck of its Investor Day is that the turnaround is already visible in the numbers. The first half of FY26 delivered comparable EBIT of A$27–30m, up materially on the prior year, with Group sales rising 3.1% despite a soft discretionary backdrop. Canada posted record same‑store sales growth of 6.1%; Australia grew 4.8%; New Zealand returned to positive territory with 1.8% growth. Gross margin held steady at roughly 61% even with elevated metal input costs. Inventory was reduced by A$11m, and the Group finished the half in a positive net cash position of around A$20m.

These are not the metrics of a business in disarray. They reflect a company that has tightened execution, sharpened its operating rhythm, and re‑established commercial discipline. The Investor Day message is that the transformation is structural rather than cyclical. The brand portfolio has been simplified from five banners to two engines — Michael Hill as accessible modern luxury and Bevilles as value. Everything else is being wound down or absorbed. The simplification is not cosmetic; it is a capital‑allocation reset that frees management bandwidth and reduces operational drag.

A Clear Path to Margin Expansion

The most important strategic signal is the company’s explicit path to a 10% EBIT margin. The levers are familiar but now presented as integrated rather than isolated. Store productivity is improving through better rostering, more accurate inventory allocation, and a more disciplined approach to labour hours. Revenue growth is being diversified across bridal, bespoke, and digital. Gross profit is being supported by product engineering that manages metal price volatility without compromising perceived value. Operating leverage is emerging as the store network modernises and Canada scales.

The company’s ability to hold gross margin flat in the face of record metal prices is a case in point. The deck highlights a subtle but powerful capability: Michael Hill is engineering product to manage metal price volatility. By controlling design, materials, and construction, the company can shift perceived value without shifting gold weight. This is a quiet hedge against commodity volatility and a meaningful contributor to gross‑margin stability.

Demand: Subdued, But Not Weak

The consumer environment remains subdued, but the company’s trading data suggests demand is holding up better than sentiment implies. Bridal continues to perform strongly; bespoke is outperforming; digital is growing without margin dilution. The loyalty program — responsible for more than 80% of transactions; is functioning as a structural moat. Loyalty customers deliver higher average transaction volume and that is a material advantage in a soft consumer market.

Digital performance is particularly important. The Investor Day deck makes a point that many will gloss over: digital margins are in line with store margins. Most retailers suffer digital margin dilution; Michael Hill does not. A majority of digital sales convert in‑store via Click & Collect, which means digital growth supports store productivity rather than cannibalising it. This is a rare structural advantage and a key reason the EBIT margin target is credible.

AI: A Real Operating Model Shift, With Uneven Depth

The presentation positions AI as a meaningful operating‑model shift rather than a marketing flourish, although the level of specificity varies across functions. The clearest signals sit in inventory, rostering, and demand forecasting, where the company is already using machine‑learning models to optimise stock allocation, improve replenishment accuracy, and match labour hours to trading patterns.

These initiatives are not framed as cost‑out programs; they are presented as tools that lift store productivity and reduce working‑capital friction. The merchandising and pricing references are more directional than detailed, suggesting early‑stage experimentation rather than fully embedded systems.

Clienteling is described as AI‑enabled, but the deck stops short of explaining whether this means personalised recommendations, automated outreach, or simply better data visibility for store teams. The overarching message is that AI is intended to amplify human capability across the network, yet the presentation leaves open the question of how far these tools have progressed beyond pilot scale.

In our view, the company is signalling genuine intent, but the operational depth remains uneven. It appears advanced in inventory and rostering, emerging in pricing and clienteling, and still largely conceptual in broader retail decision‑making.

Canada: The Growth Engine

The company is explicit that Canada is the long‑term growth engine. The market is under‑penetrated, brand maturity is lower, and digital adoption is still developing. The store ambition — 85–90 stores — is not simply expansion; it is a reweighting of the Group’s profit mix. Canada’s bridal and diamond categories have significant headroom, and the early performance of the Yorkdale flagship suggests the brand can stretch into higher‑value segments. The Investor Day deck positions Canada as the geography where the multi‑year EBIT uplift will come from. Australia remains stable; New Zealand is recovering; Canada is the runway.

Bevilles: A Disciplined Reset

Bevilles, acquired in 2023, has been a source of investor uncertainty. The presentation addresses this directly. The reset is being run through a strict stage‑gate capital framework. Expansion will not resume until same‑store sales, gross profit, and store‑level profitability are proven. Capital will only be deployed if returns exceed cost of capital. This is unusual discipline for a value retailer and reduces the risk of another underperforming roll‑out. The message is that Bevilles is being reset, not written off. The value segment remains attractive, but the company is unwilling to chase growth without evidence.

A New Era In Leadership Not a Reset

The leadership transition is handled with understated confidence. The company acknowledges the significance of losing both Sir Michael Hill and Daniel Bracken, but the Investor Day tone is forward‑looking rather than defensive. Jonathan Waecker’s early impact is visible in the trading trajectory: the final ten weeks of FY26H1 delivered a materially improved performance relative to the early‑year update. The message is that the company has moved past the uncertainty phase. Governance is stable, the executive team is aligned, and the strategy is coherent.

Our Assessment: A Business With Momentum, Not Memory

The Investor Day presentation is designed to reassure investors that Michael Hill is not a legacy retailer navigating a difficult consumer cycle. It is a business with a simplified brand architecture, a credible margin‑expansion pathway, a structurally advantaged digital model, a high‑value loyalty engine, disciplined capital allocation, and a multi‑market growth runway led by Canada. Demand is subdued, but not weak.

The company’s trading data shows resilience rather than fragility. The leadership transition has not derailed execution. The strategic narrative is sharper than it has been in years. In our view, the presentation marks a clear pivot: Michael Hill is no longer selling a turnaround story; it is selling a growth story with structural levers, disciplined capital, and a credible margin ambition.