Why is Palantir stock falling while Nvidia rises?

Investors have been rotating out of expensive AI software stocks like Palantir (NASDAQ:PLTR) and into AI chipmakers like Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA), whose demand is easier to see and measure. Palantir's business is growing fast, but it trades at over 140 times earnings, so investors nervous about lofty valuations have favoured hardware names with more tangible AI demand. Other software stocks like Salesforce and Oracle have slipped for the same reason.

Is Palantir stock a buy right now?

It depends on your risk tolerance. Palantir is a high-quality, fast-growing business, first-quarter revenue jumped 85%, but at over 140 times earnings it is priced for near-perfect execution for years. That leaves little room for error and makes the stock volatile. For long-term believers, pullbacks can offer entry points, but chasing it at these valuations is risky, and some prominent investors, including short-seller Michael Burry, have bet against it, though Burry covered about half of that position in late June.

Are Palantir and Nvidia competitors?

No, they are actually partners. Palantir and Nvidia have expanded a partnership to run Nvidia's AI models within secure, sovereign environments for government agencies. So the fact that Nvidia rises while Palantir falls is not one business beating the other, it reflects how investors are pricing risk, favouring the tangible demand of chips over the high expectations built into software valuations.

Why is Palantir's valuation so high?

Palantir trades at over 140 times earnings because investors have priced in years of rapid future growth, driven by its fast-growing AI software business and strong government and commercial demand. The risk is that such a high valuation assumes near-flawless execution, so even strong results may not push the stock higher, and any slowdown can trigger sharp falls.

Nvidia Soars, Palantir Slips: Is AI Software Out of Favour?

KEY POINTS

Palantir fell again while Nvidia rose, extending a pattern seen for weeks.
Investors have been rotating out of expensive AI software stocks and into AI chipmakers with clearer demand.
We see the core issue as valuation: Palantir trades at over 140 times earnings, leaving no room for error.
The twist: Palantir's business is booming and it even partners with Nvidia, so this is about price, not performance.

Palantir (NASDAQ:PLTR) slipped again on Friday, down about 1.5%, on a day when Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) rose more than 3%. It is a split that has played out repeatedly in recent weeks: the AI chipmaker powers ahead while the AI software star struggles. The obvious question is whether investors are quietly rotating out of AI software and into AI hardware, and what that means for anyone holding these names. Here is how we read it.

The Great AI Rotation

There is a genuine shift happening, and it is not just these two stocks. Through recent weeks, investors have been pulling money out of high-priced AI software companies and moving it into chipmakers that benefit from booming AI demand. Other software names like Salesforce and Oracle have slipped alongside Palantir, while Nvidia has powered to fresh highs.

Why the preference for hardware? The demand story for AI chips is easier to see and measure: every new AI data centre needs Nvidia’s processors, and the orders are concrete. The same is true for memory makers like Micron, which have soared on visible AI demand.

AI software companies, by contrast, face a tougher question: can they keep growing fast enough to justify sky-high valuations? In our view, that is the heart of the rotation: when investors get nervous, they favour the clearer, more tangible demand story, and right now that is chips.

Stocks Down Under

Pitt Street Research · AFSL 1265112

ASX insiders bought these 5 stocks.
The market hasn't noticed yet.

Disclosed by law. Missed by most investors. 129 trades tracked by us.

Top buys

top sells

cOVERAGE

FY 0

Free

NO Credit card

Why Palantir Keeps Getting Punished

Here is the part that surprises people: Palantir’s business is not the problem. Its results have been excellent, with first-quarter revenue up 85% from a year earlier and strong profits. The issue is entirely about price.

Even after falling around 25% this year, Palantir still trades at over 140 times earnings, an extraordinarily high valuation. That may sound abstract, but the implication is simple: at that price, the stock needs years of near-perfect growth just to justify where it already trades.

When a stock is priced for perfection, even great news struggles to push it higher, and any wobble sends it lower. Famous short-seller Michael Burry has criticised Palantir’s valuation and bet against the stock, though he covered about half of that short position in late June. The concern is not that Palantir is a bad company; it is that the price already assumes a flawless future.

The Investor’s Takeaway

So what should investors make of this? The irony is that Palantir and Nvidia are not even rivals here; they are partners, working together on secure AI systems for governments. This split is not about one business beating the other. It is about how investors are pricing risk: rewarding the tangible demand of chips, and punishing the lofty expectations baked into software.

Our view: for Nvidia holders, the rally reflects genuine, visible demand, though even great stocks can run ahead of themselves. For Palantir, the story is more delicate. This is a superb business at a demanding price, and until the valuation cools or growth proves it can keep pace, the stock is likely to stay volatile. For long-term believers, that volatility can create entry points on pullbacks, but chasing it is risky.

The key takeaway is that this rotation is about valuation and sentiment, not business quality. When the market’s appetite for expensive software returns, names like Palantir can rebound quickly, as they have already started to in July. Until then, the safer, clearer trade is the one investors keep choosing: the picks and shovels of the AI boom.