Who Should Invest in Coal Stocks?
Investing in coal stocks requires a clear view of risk, income needs, and comfort with the energy transition. In our view, the following types of investors may still find this sector appealing.
Coal prices remain cyclical, but established miners continue to generate reliable cash flows. Investors willing to ride out short-term swings might see value in the steady earnings these companies still deliver, supported by ongoing Asian demand reported by the IEA.
Several ASX-listed coal producers continue to pay strong dividends. We're not talking about token payouts, we're talking about returns backed by consistent export revenue and disciplined cost control, which can appeal to those seeking income stability.
Coal stocks respond sharply to policy shifts, geopolitical risks, and commodity cycles. Investors with higher risk tolerance who can absorb these fluctuations might view the sector as an opportunity rather than a threat.
Is the market discounting coal miners too heavily because of the renewables narrative? Some companies trade at low multiples despite resilient earnings, creating potential openings for contrarian investors.
Coal comes with ethical and environmental implications. Those who separate ESG concerns from investment decisions – or focus on the ongoing necessity of steelmaking coal, may still see coal stocks as a suitable addition to their portfolio.
Get the Latest Stock Market Insights for Free with
Stocks Down Under & Pitt Street Research
Join our newsletter and receive exclusive insights, market trends, investment tips, and updates delivered directly to your inbox. Don't miss out – subscribe today and make informed investment decisions.
The Role of Coal in Australia's Economy
Coal remains one of Australia's largest exports, generating billions in revenue despite energy transition pressures. The country exported approximately 162.7 million tonnes in the first half of 2025, though the 5.6% year-on-year decline signals that demand is softening.
What's significant is that Australia produces two distinct coal types: thermal coal for electricity generation and metallurgical coal for steel production. Major producers like Whitehaven Coal now derive 64% of production from higher-margin metallurgical coal, reflecting the industry's strategic pivot toward the more resilient steelmaking market.
Global Coal Production and Market Dynamics
Global coal trade reached an all-time high of 1.55 billion tonnes in 2024, but the International Energy Agency projects unprecedented consecutive declines in both 2025 and 2026. This suggests the global coal market has likely peaked. China drives this decline, with imports expected to fall approximately 76 million tonnes in 2025 due to strong domestic production and elevated stockpiles.
For Australian exporters, this creates intensifying competition. Indonesia captured 38.8% of global seaborne coal exports in 2024 compared to Australia's 26%, largely by offering lower-cost coal to price-sensitive Chinese and Southeast Asian buyers. In our view, Australian producers must compete on quality rather than price, focusing on high-energy, low-ash coal that commands premiums in markets like Japan and South Korea.
Morgan Stanley forecasts metallurgical coal prices will hover around $200 per tonne by mid-2025, with thermal coal around $135 per tonne. This implies modest 5-10% upside from current levels but signals the market doesn't expect a dramatic recovery..
The Role of Government Regulations on Coal Stocks
Environmental regulations increasingly shape coal stocks' profitability. Queensland's royalty rates can reach 15% for premium-priced coal, significantly impacting profit margins when coal prices soften. Internationally, China's domestic coal production policies directly affect import volumes, while India's "Atmanirbhar" self-reliance policy aims to reduce coal import dependence.
The key insight for investors is that government policies, not just market forces, will increasingly determine coal demand. Companies with diversified export markets are better positioned to navigate these regulatory headwinds than those heavily dependent on a single country.
The Influence of Global Events on Coal Markets
China's economic growth trajectory matters more than any other single factor. When Chinese steel production slows, metallurgical coal prices typically follow within weeks. Weather patterns also play a crucial role. India's extended heatwaves in 2024 drove electricity demand higher, temporarily boosting thermal coal consumption, while strong hydropower production in China during the same period reduced coal-fired generation needs.
For investors, this means coal stocks will remain volatile, responding to factors ranging from monsoon strength to Chinese infrastructure spending announcements.
The Future of Coal in a Renewable Energy Era
The uncomfortable truth is that long-term demand faces structural decline. China, the world's largest coal consumer, achieved a net decrease in emissions in 2024, and coal use for power generation likely peaked that year. Southeast Asian countries are building 10 times more renewable capacity than coal capacity in their current pipeline.
However, structural decline doesn't mean immediate collapse. Coal still accounts for significant electricity generation across Asia, and the transition will take decades rather than years. Steel production remains dependent on metallurgical coal, with green hydrogen alternatives still prohibitively expensive. The investment question isn't whether coal demand will eventually decline; it will, but whether current coal stocks can generate sufficient cash returns before that decline becomes severe.
3 Best ASX Coal Stocks to Buy Now in 2025
Whitehaven Coal (ASX: WHC)
Whitehaven Coal appears to be the best-positioned large-cap coal producer. Trading around $7.23, the company forecasts producing 35-39.5 million tonnes in FY25, with 64% from higher-margin metallurgical coal. Whitehaven completed significant acquisitions of BHP's Blackwater and Daunia mines in 2024, expanding its production base while maintaining a debt-free balance sheet with $1.2 billion in cash.
Yancoal Australia (ASX: YAL)
Yancoal Australia (ASX: YAL) offers scale and diversification across multiple mines in New South Wales and Queensland. The company produced 36.9 million tonnes in 2024, predominantly thermal coal, and trades with an attractive valuation given its cash generation capabilities. Yancoal's joint ventures with major miners provide operational stability.
New Hope Corporation (ASX: NHC)
New Hope Corporation (ASX: NHC) provides exposure to the thermal coal market through its Bengalla mine ownership and Queensland assets. With forecast production of 10.8-11.9 million tonnes in FY25, New Hope is smaller than Whitehaven and Yancoal but benefits from producing high-energy low-ash coal that commands premium prices.
3 Best ASX Coal Stocks to Buy Now in 2025
FAQs on Investing in Coal Stocks
Our Analysis on ASX Coal Stocks
Our 5 ASX Predictions for 2026!
This article outlines 5 ASX Predictions for 2026 that Stocks Down Under puts its neck on the line to assert…
Here are 6 ASX Resources Stocks With Feasibility Studies due in 2026!
This article outlines 6 ASX Resources Stocks With Feasibility Studies due in 2026! The companies mentioned in this article are…
Here are 6 ASX mining services stocks to look at (other than Mineral Resources)
There are plenty of ASX mining services stocks doing well right now due to the booming gold and iron ore…
Zeotech (ASX:ZEO): Stronger and low-carbon concrete derived from Queensland kaolin!
Zeotech (ASX:ZEO) is attempting to play a part in helping reduce emissions from the construction sector. Over the last few…
Here are 5 ASX resources stocks with New Zealand projects
In this article, we’re taking a look at ASX resources stocks with New Zealand projects. It is easy for investors…
South32 (ASX:S32): Is it the dark horse amongst ASX 200 miners or have cyclones and commodity prices hit it too hard?
South32 (ASX:S32) began life as a spinoff from BHP back in 2015, capitalised at $9bn. In mid-October 2025, it is…