Silver Mines (ASX:SVL) Crashes 22% on Permitting Setback: Buy the Dip or Avoid?

Silver Mines: Buy the dip or avoid?

Silver Mines (ASX: SVL) dropped 22% to 18 cents yesterday after announcing it must redo ecological surveys for its Bowdens Silver Project. This extends an already uncertain approval timeline. For investors who’ve watched this stock climb 178% over the past year, yesterday’s sell-off raises a simple question: Is this a chance to buy cheaper, or a red flag to stay away?

The timing is frustrating. Silver prices have surged more than 130% in 2025, and while they recently tested record highs near A$110 per ounce, they are currently consolidating around the A$103-$105 mark. Yet Silver Mines shares have pulled back sharply, suggesting the market sees real risk that approvals may take longer than expected.

What are the Best ASX Silver stocks to invest in right now?

Check our buy/sell tips

Bowdens Permitting Saga Continues

Some background helps explain what happened. In April 2023, the Independent Planning Commission approved Bowdens, Australia’s largest undeveloped silver deposit, holding 71.7 million ounces in reserves. Everything looked on track until August 2024, when the NSW Court of Appeal cancelled that approval over concerns about how a power line to the mine site was assessed.

Recent law changes created a path back to approval. The Planning Secretary recently confirmed the power line issue has been resolved. However, yesterday’s update brought bad news: the company must now refresh its ecological surveys and prepare a new biodiversity assessment.

Managing Director Jo Battershill put a positive spin on it, saying this approach puts the project on “a stronger footing for a successful redetermination.” That may be true legally, but investors see it differently. Every new requirement pushes back the timeline and burns more cash.

While the delay is frustrating, the company has now provided a concrete roadmap: it expects to complete the refreshed ecological surveys by early 2026 and submit the new biodiversity assessment for redetermination by mid-2026. Silver Mines admitted the approval process faces a “changing regulatory landscape” beyond its control. For a company with almost no revenue, this uncertainty is the main risk.

Why Bowdens Still Matters for Silver Investors

Despite the setback, the underlying asset remains impressive. Bowdens is not just Australia’s largest undeveloped silver deposit; it ranks among the biggest globally. The December 2024 study outlined strong economics: a A$331 million mine producing 53 million ounces of silver over 16.5 years at all-in costs of around A$25 per ounce.

With silver now trading above A$110 per ounce, the profit margins would be substantial if the mine gets built. More than 85% of Bowdens’ revenue would come directly from silver sales, giving shareholders direct exposure to any further price rises.

The company finished the September quarter with A$43.67 million in cash, following a successful A$34 million capital raising in August 2025, providing a substantial runway for the redetermination process. This means Silver Mines isn’t facing immediate pressure to raise more capital.

The Investor’s Takeaway

Here’s the bull case: Bowdens is a world-class project in a strong silver market. Yesterday’s 22% drop creates a cheaper entry point for believers. The asset hasn’t changed; only the timeline has stretched. At a market cap of approximately A$386 million, investors are weighing a significant valuation against a deposit worth potentially billions once developed.

The bear case is simple: Permitting risk now dominates the story. There’s no production, no revenue timeline, and no clarity on when approval arrives. Silver Mines has spent over A$100 million developing Bowdens but remains entirely dependent on regulators.

Our view: This is a high-risk, high-reward bet on both silver prices and regulatory outcomes. Patient investors comfortable with uncertainty may see value here. Those wanting near-term catalysts should wait for clearer signals from NSW planning authorities before committing capital.