Rio Tinto (ASX:RIO) Drops 6% on Glencore Merger Talks: Is This the Buying Opportunity or a Warning Sign?

Rio Tinto and Glencore’s Merger Proposal

Rio Tinto (ASX: RIO) fell over 6 per cent on Friday after Glencore confirmed the two mining giants are in early merger talks. The deal would combine Rio’s A$200 billion market cap with Glencore’s £53 billion to create a resources powerhouse worth roughly US$260 billion in enterprise value. Yet the market reaction tells an interesting story: Glencore shares surged 10 per cent on the news, while Rio dropped sharply.

This split reaction matters. Glencore shareholders clearly see big value in the deal, but Rio investors are heading for the exits. Understanding the reason behind it is the key to deciding whether this pullback is a buying opportunity or a warning sign.

What are the Best ASX Mining Stocks to invest in right now?

Check our buy/sell tips

Why Rio Tinto Shareholders Are Nervous About This Deal

The biggest concern is what Rio would be taking on. Glencore remains one of the world’s largest coal producers, running 26 mines across Australia, Colombia, and South Africa. Rio Tinto, by contrast, sold its last coal assets back in 2018 to focus on cleaner commodities. A merger would effectively undo that decision.

This matters because many large investors now screen out coal exposure. If Rio absorbs Glencore’s coal business, some ESG-focused funds may be forced to sell, creating selling pressure on the stock.

There’s also recent history to consider. Glencore approached Rio with a similar proposal in late 2024, and those talks went nowhere. The fact that negotiations collapsed just over a year ago suggests reaching an agreement won’t be easy this time either.

Regulatory hurdles add more uncertainty. A deal this size would face intense scrutiny across Australia, the UK, Europe, and potentially China. The approval process could drag on for years. Under UK takeover rules, Rio must announce by February 5 whether it will make a formal offer or walk away.

The Bull Case: Why Some See Opportunity

Despite these concerns, Rio’s underlying business remains rock solid. The company holds world-class iron ore assets in the Pilbara, a growing copper portfolio through the massive Oyu Tolgoi mine in Mongolia, and significant aluminium operations globally.

If a merger happened on favourable terms, the combined company would dominate copper, iron ore, and aluminium markets. Copper is especially valuable right now given its critical role in electric vehicles, renewable energy, and grid infrastructure.

However, we believe Rio’s quality doesn’t depend on this deal happening. The company’s premium assets and disciplined management remain intact regardless of whether merger talks succeed or fail.

The Investor’s Takeaway for Rio Tinto

At current levels around A$143 per share, Rio Tinto trades at around 13 times earnings with a dividend yield near 4.5 per cent. For a miner of this quality, that valuation looks reasonable rather than cheap or expensive.

For long-term investors comfortable with some uncertainty, this dip could offer a sensible entry point into one of Australia’s best resources companies. If merger talks collapse, the stock could recover quickly once the uncertainty lifts.

Conservative investors may prefer to wait for clarity. The February 5 deadline will force Rio’s hand one way or another. If Glencore’s coal assets become part of Rio’s portfolio, it would fundamentally change the investment case for shareholders who valued Rio’s cleaner positioning.

Our view: Rio Tinto remains a quality business regardless of what happens with Glencore. The deal uncertainty creates near-term risk, but patient investors may find current prices attractive. Watch the February deadline closely.