GrainCorp (ASX: GNC) Posts $308M EBITDA But Shares Drop 12%: What’s Behind the Sell-Off?

GrainCorp (ASX: GNC) shares fell 12% to $7.87 this week despite reporting EBITDA of $308 million, up 15% on the prior year. While the headline number looked solid, investors focused on what mattered most: reported profit collapsed 35% to just $40 million. The market’s reaction makes clear that moving more grain means nothing when margins deteriorate at every level. With management warning of ongoing pressure into FY26, this result has raised serious questions about the dividend’s sustainability.

What are the Best Agriculture Stock to invest in right now?

Check our buy/sell tips

Record Volumes Couldn’t Overcome the Margin Squeeze

GrainCorp’s operations showed genuine strength:

– GrainCorp handled 31.6 million tonnes – up 12.8% from last year, benefiting from strong east coast production of 34.7 million tonnes
– Record oilseed crush – 557,000 tonnes processed, an all-time high demonstrating operational excellence
– Strong market position – clear beneficiary of bumper Australian harvest

The problem? None of this operational success translated to profit. The company’s international business saw volumes rise, but margins collapsed. The cause: a global wheat record of 818 million tonnes created fierce competition and pushed margins to five-year lows. Northern Hemisphere crops essentially crushed Australian export margins, leaving GrainCorp competing in an oversupplied market with no pricing power.
Adding to the pain, the company booked a $26 million impairment on its Canadian operations, signalling management sees no improvement ahead. A strategic review, possibly leading to divestment, appears likely. For investors, the message is clear: GrainCorp can move grain efficiently, but operational success means little when margins are under siege.

Strong EBITDA Masks Bottom-Line Collapse and Dividend Risk

GrainCorp posted solid EBITDA growth, up 15% to $308 million, and underlying NPAT rose 13% to $87 million. But reported NPAT fell sharply by 35% to $40 million, with a $26 million Canadian impairment contributing to the $47 million gap from underlying profit. This write-down reflects real asset value loss, and despite strong volumes, margins weakened across the board.
The dividend remains at 48 cents per share, fully franked, offering a 5.4% yield at the current $7.87 share price. However, the payout ratio hit 88% of underlying earnings, and more concerning, the cash payout ratio reached 108.7% of operating cash flow. GrainCorp is now distributing more cash than it generates, a clear warning sign for income investors.
Fortunately, Graincorp holds $321 million in cash and carries no debt, giving it short-term flexibility to maintain dividends without risking financial stability. But FY26 will be critical. If margins stay tight and cash flow doesn’t rebound, the board may have to choose between protecting shareholder returns and preserving the balance sheet.
For now, the dividend looks safe, but FY27 could be a turning point if profitability doesn’t improve.

The Investor’s Takeaway: Value Trap or Temporary Cycle?

The bull case:
– Early FY26 receipts of 4.2M tonnes show momentum continues
– A pristine balance sheet ($321M cash, no debt) provides strategic options
– Macquarie’s $9 target sees margin recovery once oversupply normalises

The bear case:
– Management is guiding ongoing margin pressure into FY26
– Global wheat stocks at 270M tonnes mean recovery isn’t imminent
– Canadian business under review; further write-downs possible
– Dividend unsustainable at 108.7% cash payout if conditions don’t improve

For income investors: The 5.4% fully franked yield compensates for risk if you’re comfortable waiting 2-3 years for margin normalisation. Hold for dividend income, but watch FY26 cash flow closely at the February 2026 AGM.

For growth investors: Better opportunities exist where volume growth actually creates shareholder value rather than being absorbed by margin compression.

Current holders: Hold for income, monitor cash flow.

New investors: Wait for margin stability evidence, or enter now, understanding this is a patience play, betting on global grain market rebalancing.
At $7.87, you’re buying operational strength at a fair price, but financial returns depend entirely on margin recovery that management can’t yet promise.